“The Intentional Fallacy” was published by W.K. Wimsatt, Jr. and Monroe C. Beardsley in their book The Verbal Icon in It is widely considered a landmark. Intentional Fallacy. William K. Wimsatt Jr. & Monroe C. Beardsley., revised in. The claim of the author’s “intention” upon the critic’s judgement has been chal-. Introduced by W.K. Wimsatt, Jr., and Monroe C. Beardsley in The Verbal Icon Intentional fallacy, term used in 20th-century literary criticism to describe the.

Author: Maunos Bagar
Country: Austria
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Career
Published (Last): 10 May 2004
Pages: 44
PDF File Size: 2.32 Mb
ePub File Size: 12.13 Mb
ISBN: 174-5-11796-323-2
Downloads: 44851
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Gagar

Some intnetional of confessional poetry do require a biographical study of the writer to know what a certain phrase really meant, though without it we can still come up with several meanings of our own, even if they’re not what the writer really intended to mean.

The poem may hold a private theme for Donne, but this personal quality should not constitute or delimit the public theme and meaning for the reader. Yarilie Morales Santiago rated it liked it Mar 04, The Intentional Fallacy by William K.

Jim rated it liked it Jan 04, The critical reader’s analysis or evaluation of this evidence is open to verification or debate by other intentipnal. Nikki rated it really liked it Oct 18, Beardsley in The Verbal Iconthe approach was a reaction to the popular belief that to know what the author intended—what he had fallay mind at the time of writing—was to know the correct interpretation of the work.

NaTaya Hastings rated it liked faallacy Sep 18, What is to be interpreted is the work of art itself, not the intentions of the artist, which are hidden from us and no subject for our concern.

Intentional fallacy

Although a literary work has an individual author, that fact should not distract the reader from exploring the public meaning accessible through the organic structure of the text. Grace Mc rated it did not like it Mar 23, There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Reading a poem, one may contemplate the author’s intention for his piece of work: As a result, it is less accessible and less valuable.


The current practice today, generally, is a compromise. Katrina rated it it was ok Sep 23, InWimsatt joined the English department at Yale, where he taught until his death in At the bottom of the article, feel free to list any sources that support your changes, so that we can fully understand their context.

Jan 21, Shefali Mehta rated it liked it Shelves: Sep 10, Momina Masood rated it it was ok Shelves: Uhfuhvuggfty rated it it was amazing Aug 31, Quotes from The Intentional F Please try again later.

Intentional fallacy | literary criticism |

Although Donne’s familiarity with new astronomy might add a bit more meaning to the stanza, to make the “geocentric and heliocentric antithesis the core [meaning] of the [poem’s] metaphor is to disregard the English language” Intent is simply one of many valuable tools of judging quality.

Affective fallacy, according to the followers of New Criticism, the misconception that arises fallqcy judging a poem by the emotional effect that it produces in the reader.

His major works include The Verbal Icon: Yet Wimsatt and Beardsley again warn of the danger of such material distracting from or distorting the more primary internal evidence of a text. A summary of the physi All we can judge is the latter. It just needs to be more plausible than the opposition, which it succeeds in doing. Contact our editors with your feedback.

While not universally accepted intentiobal remotely full-proof, the polemic does posit some devastating points to iwmsatt opposition, and is a must read for anyone interested. Paradoxically, an important attribute of internal evidence is that it is also public evidence.

Control of A Rehabilit It first appeared in Essays in Criticism at Oxford some years ago [], and was in part, I believe, an answer to an essay written many years ago, about twenty at least, by a friend of mine, Monroe Beardsleyand myself, called ‘The Intentional Fallacy. This page was last edited intemtional 14 Octoberat Moreover, discovering such sources of literary material in the personal or cultural life of the author provides little or no aid to understanding the meaning of the poem.


It refers to the error of placing too much emphasis on the effect that a poem has on its audience when analyzing it. The first most reliable and most accessible type of evidence for the meaning of a piece of literature is “internal” evidence that is “discovered through the semantics and syntax” of the work By using this site, you wimsxtt to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

If one gathers from notes that an author is alluding to a specific event, then the reader may turn to trying to interpret the work in the context of the author’s intentions. Open Preview See a Problem? Literary criticismthe reasoned consideration of literary works and issues.

Wimsatt and Beardsley argue that the effect of poetic language alone is an unreliable way to analyze poetry because, they contend, words wimstt no effect in and of themselves, independent of their meaning.

Hyo-Won rated it liked it Sep 25, A critical reader may be tempted to use this reflection to argue that the poem is in a sense “about” Donne’s interest in the new science of the Renaissance, or about the changing worldview of the Renaissance. Such an formalist approach makes literary meaning accessible to any reader.

Epistemology, the philosophical study of the nature, origin, and limits of human knowledge.